Description

Introduction

Time stands as one of life’s most profound enigmas. Within his 2017 book titled “The Order of Time,” physicist Carlo Rovelli embarks on a journey to unravel the intricate tapestry of temporal concepts, spanning from the rudimentary to the intricate. Over the course of history, philosophers, artists, and scientists have all delved into this notion, leading to a continuously evolving understanding. Rovelli’s exploration encompasses not only the bedrock principles of physics but also delves into Einstein’s theory of relativity, the intricacies of quantum mechanics, and his own groundbreaking studies on thermal time and loop quantum gravity. Through a tapestry of explanations, Rovelli illuminates the multifaceted nature of time, infusing it with a deeply human sense of wonder.

Chapter One: The Crumbling Concept of Time

Surprisingly, the passage of time exhibits a deceleration at lower elevations. In this context, an individual residing at sea level theoretically experiences a lesser duration of existence compared to someone dwelling on a mountain, as a clock positioned closer to the ground ticks at a slower pace than one elevated on a surface. Though minute, this phenomenon is indeed measurable. Before empirical detection became possible, it was Albert Einstein who first comprehended this notion. He proposed the concept that any massive entity, such as a celestial body like the sun or a planet, exerts an influence on the spacetime fabric enveloping it. This gravitational distortion of spacetime, in turn, affects the trajectories of other objects, compelling them towards one another. Consequently, the presence of mass causes a localized dilation of time, effectively anchoring our physical connection to the ground.

The notion of a singular “time” is a fallacy. Each event possesses its distinct “proper time,” a concept elaborated upon by Einstein’s general theory of relativity, outlining how these proper times relate to one another.

Ultimately, it’s not the concept of “proper time” that occupies our thoughts; rather, it’s the ceaseless current of time itself. Our fascination lies in the interplay of causality—how the past shapes the present. Engineer Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot unveiled the principle that heat solely flows from hot to cold environments, representing the sole physical directive distinguishing between past and future. Heat exhibits unidirectional behavior, unlike, for instance, the rebound of a ball.

Amidst these principles, entropy emerges as a pivotal concept—a notion initially postulated by German physicist Rudolf Clausius. Entropy is a quantifiable measure that only increases or remains constant. Austrian physicist Ludwig Boltzmann introduced the idea of atoms and molecules in a state of agitation, resulting in heat, and the ensuing concept of entropy as a manifestation of disorder. This inherent disorder stems from our limited capacity to distinctly perceive phenomena.

Furthermore, temporal dilation accompanies objects in motion. This effect becomes evident as objects accelerate. When stationary, your clock registers time as t, yet as you move, it measures time at t’. Consequently, time appears to contract for objects in motion.

Chapter Two: What Is Now?

The concept of the present moment presents a formidable challenge. Our surroundings reveal the actions of those nearby, allowing us to infer their current activities. However, if these individuals are situated on a distant planet, the light carrying their actions takes more than a mere few nanoseconds to reach us. Consequently, their “now” diverges from ours, and it could take years before we become privy to their actions. Thus, only objects in close proximity to us truly exist in the present.

To illustrate the temporal structure of the universe, one can envision two cones, representative of the past and the future, converging at their tips to form the present. These configurations, known as light cones, constitute a significant element within the fabric of spacetime.

Days and hours have long formed the foundational framework for our perception of time. Historically, each city maintained its distinct local time, owing to the unique rising of the sun across the globe. The resolution to this temporal disparity came in 1883 with the establishment of time zones. Aristotle speculated that in the absence of change, time would remain stagnant, while Einstein recognized the impossibility of achieving perfect clock synchronization. Isaac Newton posited that time relentlessly advances, regardless of appearances, with its true passage calculable but not directly perceivable—a quality clocks endeavor to depict.

Likewise, Aristotle’s understanding defined space as the encompassing realm of a given entity. Conversely, Newton, adopting a more theoretical stance, regarded space as an immutable and tangible construct. Einstein’s contribution further expanded the concept by introducing the gravitational field to the notion of spacetime. While space and time are not self-sustaining in isolation, they exhibit a level of independence from their surroundings. Each of these three physicists contributed to defining segments of the spacetime framework, yet the fabric of spacetime also accommodates quantum characteristics.

Chapter Three: The Big Change

Quantum mechanics has profoundly shattered our previous comprehension of time, achieving this transformation through three fundamental principles. The initial notion is that of granularity, implying that time is quantized rather than flowing continuously. It possesses both definable and undefined values, exhibiting a minimal temporal unit beyond which time loses its meaningful existence.

The second concept, indeterminacy, has significantly altered our temporal perspective. Foreseeing the precise location of an electron at a specific instant becomes an intractable endeavor; instead, the entire scenario is governed by probabilities. This phenomenon is encapsulated in the concept of superposition.

The third principle expounds that the definiteness of an electron’s position only emerges in relation to the entities with which it interacts. While intricate to grasp, this principle draws parallels between the functioning of space and time.

The result of these transformative ideas is the reshaping of our approach to spacetime. Formerly held concepts of spacetime no longer suffice, necessitating a fresh inquiry into the intricacies of quantum gravity.

Chapter Four: The Assumption of a World Without Time

The universe’s essence lies in change, not in unchanging constancy. It comprises events, not mere substances. Events are delineated by the interplay of time and space, representing the “when” and the “where” of occurrences. Relativity harmoniously coexists with this perspective. The governing laws of physics pertain to alterations within systems, not the systems themselves. Schrödinger’s equations, Maxwell’s equations, and Newton’s mechanics all characterize events, not static entities. Among these, time stands as the sole constituent.

Ordinarily, the present moment is regarded as the realm of reality, distinct from both the past and the future. This philosophical notion, termed presentism, acknowledges that the present lacks universal constancy. However, presentism fails to encompass the full spectrum of cosmic nature.

Conversely, eternalism posits the eternality of time, asserting that all temporal phases coexist. Yet, this proposition doesn’t align with reality. Although cosmic time lacks a fixed order, this complexity underscores the intricate temporal architecture of the universe.

Discarding the notion of time would necessitate redefining our understanding of the universe. We would need to rely on celestial bodies like the sun, moon, and sundials, establishing their interrelationships as temporal markers. The 1967 Wheeler-DeWitt equation, which describes quantum gravity, notably omits the time variable. Instead of charting changes over time, it delineates alterations relative to one another.

Loop theory posits that the fabric of reality consists of minute particles known as quanta of space. Operating within a strong probabilistic framework, it characterizes these particles through their interactions, rather than through temporal progression. These quanta form loops and spin networks, weaving intricate web-like structures. Quantum leaps manifest, yielding a dynamic portrayal of quantum spacetime. Loop quantum gravity likely stands as the most comprehensive theory encompassing spacetime and its quantum attributes, free from the conventional constraints of time.

Chapter Five: The Source and Humanity of Time

To unravel the intricacies of time, a technical approach becomes imperative. Within an isolated system, energy persistently resides. The interconnection between time and energy is undeniable, yet time itself conserves energy. In the quest to define a macroscopic state, the foundational framework of energy-defined time becomes requisite. A counterperspective emerges, suggesting that time emerges as a byproduct of blurring—manifesting as a lack of meticulous attention. Hence, “thermal time” is born, an unconventional concept seldom explored.

In the realm of quantum mechanics, comprehending time hinges on understanding quantum interaction. Alterations in a particle’s state occur based on the sequence of measuring its position and velocity. The order of these measurements influences the particle’s status in a noncommutative manner—a consequence of the fundamental quantum property preventing a seamless interchange of position and speed. This very property significantly impacts the sequencing of events across time, rendering both macroscopic states and quantum noncommutativity as defining aspects of temporal representation. Ultimately, time materializes as a manifestation of ignorance.

Blurriness catalyzes the emergence of heat and entropy as intertwined with the passage of time. Entropy, akin to velocity, exhibits relativity, influenced by both the universe’s structural configuration and its perceived haziness. The past’s lower entropy doesn’t stem from total orderliness but arises due to specific interactions. Furthermore, certain configurations are deemed exceptional despite their inherent nature.

Despite science’s objective nature, the essence of perspective consistently influences our understanding. The principle of “indexicality” elucidates the varying meanings of terms like “here,” “now,” and “me” contingent upon the observer. Thus, maintaining a nuanced viewpoint is vital when conveying explanations.

Energy’s conservation dictates its ability to transform. For instance, as mechanical energy shifts into thermal energy, the aggregate energy remains constant while entropy escalates. Energy continually morphs into distinct forms, while entropy progression remains relentless. The sources of the world’s energy boast minimal entropy. Absent entropy, thermal equilibrium would be reached, effacing the distinction between past and present. Entropy’s growth is a gradual process, not an instantaneous occurrence. Take wood—an entity with low entropy due to its meticulous molecular arrangement. Ignition triggers its rapid transformation, the surge in entropy accelerating its consumption. In essence, the universe succumbs to gradual disarray.

Echoes of a low-entropy past endure, epitomized by the moon’s craters. Our memory-laden minds and history-laden tomes stand as testaments to the enduring legacy of the past. Yet, the present evinces no precursory signs of the future. This disparity arises from the imprint left by a cessation of motion, engaging in an irreversible process that converts energy into heat, thus stifling the prospect of further change.

Chapter Six: The Human Factor

So, what role do individuals play in this intricate tapestry? We stand as events woven into the fabric of both space and time. Our perception of the universe, the way we categorize its components, and, of paramount importance, our memories collectively shape our identity. The contemporary tapestry of our lives is interwoven with threads of the past, creating an unbroken continuity of our former selves. Our existence is fundamentally entwined with the dimension of time.

Immanuel Kant asserts that our internal selves influence the passage of time, while our external selves shape the dimension of space. This concept aligns with the idea that our perception of the universe molds its response to us.

Traditionally, we’ve embraced the belief that the past lies behind us, the present is our current state, and the future remains ahead. However, this fundamental understanding of temporal progression is gradually eroding. A more nuanced reality is emerging—one where the global nature of the present is questioned and the sequence of events appears incomplete. The gravitational field governs time, while the quantum nature of the universe renders it inherently probabilistic. The universe is composed of events, not just the material entities as we perceive them. The exploration of new, more refined definitions of time might require a leap into a realm without conventional temporal constraints. Our perspective holds weight in light of the nebulousness that shrouds our comprehension of the cosmos. To simplify time would be imprudent, as it mirrors the complexity and depth inherent to human existence. Time encapsulates an emotional dimension, possibly shaping our experience even in the midst of its enigmatic nature.

 

Author’s Style

As a rule, Carlo Rovelli steers clear of inundating the reader with intricate mathematical formulas and complex explanations. Instead, he adeptly elucidates one of the universe’s most perplexing notions—time—using a clear and accessible approach. While he does delve into deeper technical intricacies in two chapters, he accompanies them with a cautionary note. At times, he might omit crucial details integral to his argument in favor of immersing himself in the marvels of physics. Additionally, his work features an extensive array of references and thoughtfully crafted illustrations portraying the concept of spacetime.

About the author

Carlo Rovelli, hailing from Italy, stands as a distinguished theoretical physicist renowned for his profound expertise in the realm of quantum gravity. His notable contributions encompass pioneering work in shaping the loop quantum gravity theory. Notably, he holds an esteemed visiting research chair at the prestigious Perimeter Institute located in Canada. Among his intellectual repertoire lies the formulation of various impactful concepts, including the notable thermal time hypothesis. Remarkably, Rovelli possesses a comprehensive understanding of both philosophy and history, further enriching his multidisciplinary pursuits.

Buy Book on Amazon